Shiloh Book Reviews

Let's hear from a few of the book experts in room 402 about how they would rate the novel, Shiloh, that our class recently read!

Shiloh will sweep you off your feet and makes you want to read more .I would rate Shiloh 4 out of 5 stars because it teaches you a moral and it makes you think about your actions. Marty, Dad ,Ma ,Dara Lynn, Becky, Shiloh ,and Judd Travers are the characters in this book . The plot is Marty wants to keep Shiloh. The conflict in the story is Marty wants to keep Shiloh but doesn’t know how. The resolution is Marty works for Judd to save shilo.my favorite part is when Marty keeps working for Judd to save Shiloh and it shows if you want something you got to work for it. The author does a good job making you think.

-By: Jessica

I would rate Shiloh 5 out of 5 stars because it is a heart warming about protecting a dog. The characters are Judd Travers, Marty, Shiloh, Mom, Dad, and Doctor. The plot is that Marty wants to keep Shiloh. The conflict is that Judd Travers is being mean to Shiloh and the resolution is that Marty tries to hide Shiloh to keep him then earns him. My favorite part about the book is that Marty loves Shiloh to death. The author Philip Reynolds Naylor does a great job at making the feelings sad and overwhelming.

-By: Madison

My favorite part is when Marty works super hard just to buy Shiloh. 

The author Phillip Reynolds Naylor does a great job at doing supporting details. I would rate Shiloh a 5 out of 5 stars because the book is just such a good supporting writing story.

-By: Cassy

Shiloh Book Review

My favorite part is when Marty gets to keep Shiloh. The author Phillip Reynolds Naylor does a great job entertaining the readers. I would rate Shiloh 5 out of 5 stars.The characters are Marty, Judd, and Shiloh.

-By: Emma Mize

I would rate Shiloh 5 out of 5 stars because it’s a heart warming story, and the plot is all about saving Shiloh and how to free him. The conflict is about how to keep Shiloh Marty solves that the problem by working for Judd . My favorite part is when Marty gets to keep Shiloh . The author is Phillip Reynolds Naylor . He does a great job of giving voice to the writing . Over all the story is about giving kindness to everyone .

-By: Emma Moroz